Lately there has been a lot of buzz about the use of eBook readers like Kindle, Nook or Sony’s Reader models and so on. In the US, there are also reports of schools acquiring and trying out eBook readers like these. The excitement is understandable as these eBook readers promise lots of things. The promise of portability, and the ability to carry lots of books at one go makes them seem very attractive. They are also “make it easy to take notes, save clippings of quotations and highlight passages we want to be able to find again.” Plus they help save the environment with less paper being used.

However, I cannot help feel that these hype does not address the main problems with reading by students which are the inability to read and getting students excited to want to read. In addition there is the issue of costs.

Seriously speaking, as much as there is that novelty value to using an ebook reader, at the end of the day it doesn’t help students to read. I hope schools that go to eBook readers as a panacea for their students ianbility to read will realise this. Good reading programs are still required whether the material they use to read is paper or a digital screen.

The novelty value of the eBook reader will also wear out once the students don’t get to read what they like. If schools today cannot meet the desires of students with reagrds to the kind of subjects that they like, will they be able to do so in electronic form? Reading is very much a personal choice. Perhaps some day schools will have that wide variety of eBooks for their students to read but will they be allowed to share theese books among their students? What are the copyright issues here? What will the licenses be like? Will it be just like that of paper books?

The eBook reader manufacturers also claim that students will be able to do wonderful things with their gadgets. How many of us make notes on our books or while we read? How do students keep these notes and quotation clippings if the Kindles are shared in school as I don’t see it happening soon that such eBook readers will be cheap enough for everyone to own? In the US, for example, many students have to be provided with daily lunches by the schools.

Is portability a real issue too? Or a “created issue”? It is not like books weigh like heavy laptops which then led to the creation of light weight netbooks. There are also magazines and comics which do not weigh much. How many books do you want to carry with you on a typical daily trip anyway? How many will you read anyway? A recent survey showed that some students at a university didn’t like using an eBook reader as opposed to more traditional media.

Lastly, the costs of such eBook readers are still quite significant. While schools still have serious problems with their budgets, adding the cost of such devices is questionable. Even if money is found for such eBook readers, is the school better off buying such devices or buying netbooks which give greater flexibility to the students in terms of what can be done with the devices?

For these reasons, I have doubts about the practicality of using eBook readers for school. I am not against technology in education. But I am against unthinking use of ICT. Technology for education must always bear in mind the objectives for its use. It must never be the tool first. It must be about the learning objectives first.